A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift
Podcast · A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift

The Dark Logic of A Modest Proposal

by ZumiLabs · 45m
0:00 45m

Transcript

Made automatically from the audio, so it may contain mistakes. Click a line to play from there.

Host 1

I want you to imagine just for a second that you are sitting down to read a perfectly formatted, impeccably researched government policy proposal.

Host 2

Right.

Host 1

You open this pamphlet, maybe you're, you know, holding it over your morning coffee, and the author is laying out a mathematically sound, completely logical plan to eradicate childhood poverty.

Host 2

And it looks completely normal at first.

Host 1

Exactly. The spreadsheets look great. The logistics are flawless. And then right in the middle of a paragraph about like supply chain optimization, the author suggests that the best way to solve the crisis is to just gather up all the impoverished one-year-olds and roast them in a pan with a little salt and pepper and serve them at high-end dinner parties.

Host 2

And the most disturbing part of the whole thing, the author doesn't even change his tone of voice.

Host 1

No, not at all.

Host 2

He just keeps right on detailing the exact, you know, profit margins of human flesh.

Host 1

It is the absolute definition of a literary trapdoor. So, welcome to the deep dive. Today we are reviewing a book. Well, I mean, technically a 1729 essay or pamphlet that features what has to be the most skin-peeling, shocking, and utterly brilliant bait and switch in the history of the English language.

Host 2

Oh, without a doubt.

Host 1

We are unpacking Dr. Jonathan Swift's masterpiece, a modest proposal.

Host 2

It's just a phenomenal piece of writing. I mean, it literally invented a new genre of dark humor.

Host 1

Yeah.

Host 2

And the reason we are reviewing this book today is because the mechanics of how Swift pulls this off, they are just as relevant now as they were nearly 300 years ago.

Host 1

Totally. So our mission here is to completely dissect this text. We want to understand the desperate historical context that birthed it, the incredibly cold, calculating economic math it uses to trap the reader, and you know, the blistering satire at its core.

Host 2

Right.

Host 1

And because this show is all about how information travels and how you get your hands on it, we're also going to review the modern delivery system that brought this 1729 text to us today.

Host 2

Yes, which is super important.

Host 1

Right. I'm talking about the Project Gutenberg project. We have the actual source text of Swift's essay alongside the incredibly detailed legal licensing of Project Gutenberg.

Host 2

It's a really fascinating comparison.

Host 1

It really is. We are going to see how a 300-year-old satire about turning human beings into commodities intersects with a modern legal framework designed to keep digital books entirely free.

Host 2

But you know, before we jump into the streets of 18th century Dublin, we really need to set the stage and offer a very clear disclaimer.

Host 1

Yeah, please do.

Host 2

Because when you read a modest proposal, you are immediately plunged into the deep historical, political, and religious conflicts of 1729 Ireland.

Host 1

Oh, yeah, it is heavy stuff.

Host 2

Very heavy. The essay relies heavily on the severe tensions of that era, specifically the demographic anxieties between the ruling Protestants and the marginalized Roman Catholics, whom the text refers to as papists. It also heavily targets the deeply strained and honestly often abusive relationship between the wealthy English landlords and the starving Irish tenants.

Host 1

Right. And we want to be incredibly clear with you, the listener, right up front. Our goal here is to explore these themes completely impartially.

Host 2

Exactly.

Host 1

We are going to examine these religious and political conflicts purely as mechanical elements of Swift's rhetorical strategy. We are conveying the ideas and the language exactly as they appear in the 1729 source material, so you can understand how the satire functions.

Host 2

We aren't taking any sides here.

Host 1

Not at all. We are not endorsing any of the historical, political, or religious viewpoints contained within it. We are simply reviewing the book and analyzing the historical ammunition Swift uses to load his literary weapon.

Host 2

Right. Because the genius of this text lies not necessarily in the politics themselves, but in how rationally and you know how coldly Swift presents a fundamentally horrific idea.

Host 1

Okay, let's unpack this. To really feel the impact of the trapwash sets, you have to step out of the modern world. I want you to transport yourself to the streets of Dublin in the year 1729.

Host 2

It's a very specific setting.

Host 1

Yeah, because before we can understand the shocking proposal itself, we have to look at the desperate, miserable reality that Swift paints in his opening paragraphs.

Host 2

He actually refers to the current state of the country as a melancholy object.

Host 1

A melancholy object.

Host 2

Right. And the opening of this essay is just a masterclass in setting a scene. Swift doesn't start with comedy. He doesn't start with irony.

Host 1

No, it's super bleak.

Host 2

It is. He starts with a very grounded, grim documentary style realism. If you are a wealthy reader in 1729, he is forcing you to look at something you usually, you know, cross the street to avoid.

Host 1

The visual imagery is relentless. I mean, he describes walking through this great town or traveling out in the country and seeing the streets, the roads, and the cabin doors, just absolutely crowded. Jam-packed. Yeah. And who is crowding them? It's female beggars. And they aren't alone. Each one is followed by three, four, or six children, all in rags.

Host 2

Yeah, just trailing behind them.

Host 1

Right. And they are importuning, like aggressively begging every single passenger for alms. You can almost hear the noise of it, you know, the desperation in the streets.

Host 2

And what's fascinating here is the immediate systemic failure he establishes right out of the gate.

Host 1

How so?

Host 2

Well, he states that these mothers, instead of being able to work for their honest livelihood, are forced to employ all their time and strolling around just to beg for sustenance for their helpless infants.

Host 1

Oh wow.

Host 2

Yeah, he's telling the reader that the economy is so fundamentally broken that honest labor isn't even an option anymore.

Host 1

And he doesn't just leave it at the current misery.

Host 2

Right.

Host 1

When I read this part, it felt incredibly modern. It reads less like an 18th century essay and much more like the opening montage of a modern documentary highlighting some systemic crisis.

Host 2

That's a really good analogy.

Host 1

You know what I mean. You have the wide shots of the crowded streets, the close-ups of the children in rags, and the voiceover explaining the grim statistics of where these kids end up. It's like a terrible branching path where all the endings are bad.

Host 2

Yeah, he outlines three specific destinies for these kids.

Host 1

Right. Break those down for us.

Host 2

Okay, first he says they will turn into thieves. And he specifically says for want of work.

Host 1

So not because they are inherently bad.

Host 2

Exactly. So a life of crime born purely out of economic necessity. If society won't give them a job, they will take what they need to survive.

Host 1

That makes sense. And the second option.

Host 2

Second, he says they will leave their dear native country to fight for the pretender in Spain.

Host 1

Okay, let's pause on that because that requires a bit of historical context. Who exactly is the pretender and why are Irish kids fighting for him?

Host 2

Right. So the pretender refers to James Francis Edward Stewart. He was the exiled Catholic claimant to the British throne.

Host 1

Okay.

Host 2

And at the time, Spain was a Catholic nation that frequently supported the pretender against the Protestant British monarchy. I see. So Swift is pointing out that the poverty in Ireland is so severe that it's literally driving young men to become mercenaries in foreign armies. They are fighting in religious and political wars against their own ruling government simply because it's a guaranteed meal.

Host 1

Man, that's pleak. And then there's the third option, which honestly might be the most chilling in its mundane commercial phrasing. He says they will sell themselves to the Barbados. What does that mean in practice?

Host 2

Meaning they will enter into indentured servitude, they will effectively sell their bodies and their labor boarding ships to cross the Atlantic to work on brutal sugar plantations in the Caribbean just to escape the starvation at home.

Host 1

So the table is set, the crisis is undeniable. Swift writes, and I'm quoting here, I think it is agreed by all parties, that this prodigious number of children is in the present deplorable state of the kingdom, a very great additional grievance.

Host 2

He's getting you, the reader, to nod along.

Host 1

Exactly. You're reading this and thinking, yeah, poverty is terrible. Yes, something must be done. Right. He says, whoever could find a fair, cheap and easy method of making these children useful members of the Commonwealth would deserve to have a statue set up in their honor.

Host 2

But this is where we have to stop and talk about the narrator. Oh, right. Because the voice speaking to us right now, the person proposing this grand solution, is not really Dr. Jonathan Swift, the clergyman and writer.

Host 1

Wait, let me push back on that for a second. Why invent a persona at all? If Swift is so angry about the state of Ireland, why not just write a furious op-ed under his own name?

Host 2

It's a fair question.

Host 1

Doesn't hiding behind a fake narrator kind of dilute his point.

Host 2

It actually amplifies it. Swift is adopting a very specific mask for this essay to mock the very people he despises.

Host 1

Okay. Who is he pretending to be?

Host 2

He is writing as a projector. In the 1700s, a projector was essentially an economic planner, a bureaucrat, or an entrepreneur who is always coming up with grand schemes or projects to solve societal issues.

Host 1

Oh. So he's basically adopting the persona of an 18th century tech bro.

Host 2

That is the perfect analogy. Yes. The projector is the 1729 equivalent of a Silicon Valley founder pitching like an algorithmic disruption to a social problem. Alright, right. They were the management consultants of their day. They viewed human suffering not as a moral tragedy to be mourned, but as a mere logistical puzzle to be solved.

Host 1

Just a data set that needed optimizing.

Host 2

Exactly. By adopting this voice, Swift isn't just attacking poverty, he's attacking the cold, soulless, institutional mindset that treats poor people like numbers on a spreadsheet.

Host 1

That makes total sense.

Host 2

And that leads us to the next phase of the trap.

Host 1

Right, the math. The projector strips away all the emotion of that opening documentary scene and replaces it with cold, hard, unfeeling statistics.

Host 2

The emotional reality is entirely replaced by the spreadsheet of human life. This is where he starts weaponizing boredom.

Host 1

Yes. I want to read off the incredibly specific math he uses because it is staggering how he breaks down the population of Ireland into raw data.

Host 2

Go for it.

Host 1

He starts at the top. The total number of souls in the kingdom is usually reckoned at 1 million and a half. 1.5 million people.

Host 2

And from that macro number, the projector begins to segment his target demographic. He calculates that within that 1.5 million, there are about 200,000 couples whose wives are breeders.

Host 1

Breeders. Just let that word sit there for a second.

Host 2

It's rough.

Host 1

He isn't calling them mothers or families or wives. He is actively using agricultural terminology.

Host 2

Yeah, completely.

Host 1

He refers to a child just dropped from its dam, which is language you strictly use for livestock, for sheep, or horses.

Host 2

Right. It's the language of a commodity market. He has already mentally placed human beings in the barnyard. Wow. So we have 200,000 breeders. Then he subtracts 30,000 couples who are able to maintain their own children.

Host 1

Yeah.

Host 2

Though he notes parenthetically that in the present distresses of the kingdom, there probably aren't even that many.

Host 1

A little darker side there.

Host 2

Yeah. But granting that, we're left with 170,000 breeders.

Host 1

Then he does the mortality math. He subtracts 50,000 for women who miscarry or whose children die by accident or disease within the first year.

Host 2

Which is so cool.

Host 1

It's like he treats miscarriages and infant mortality like inventory shrinkage. It's so jarring. And that leaves us with exactly 120,000 children of poor parents born annually.

Host 2

Right. The question then becomes, as he puts it, how this number shall be reared and provided for.

Host 1

And to answer that, he has to prove that the current system is completely bankrupt.

Host 2

Exactly. Right.

Host 1

He immediately goes through the logical dead ends of the economy. Yeah. He looks at these 120,000 infants and says, Well, we can't employ them in handicraft or agriculture. We neither build houses in the country nor cultivate land. They're utterly useless to the labor market.

Host 2

He is methodically closing off every normal avenue of societal contribution. He is proving that within the broken economic system of 1729 Ireland, a human child has zero economic value. In fact, they have negative value.

Host 1

He even brings up stealing as if it's an industry.

Host 2

Yeah, he does.

Host 1

He says they can very seldom pick up a livelihood by stealing until they arrive at six years old. Which is such a dark twisted joke.

Host 2

It really is. He treats thievery as just another trade apprenticeship that the children are failing at.

Host 1

He even drops this anecdote that he was informed by a principal gentleman in the county of Cavan who protested to him that he never knew above one or two instances of a child successfully mastering stealing under the age of six.

Host 2

Right.

Host 1

Even in a part of the kingdom supposedly renowned for its quick proficiency in that art. He says before age six, they were just probationers in stealing. It's hilarious, but it's so incredibly bleak.

Host 2

And that leads to the ultimate bureaucratic grievance, you know, the core of the commodity problem. The projector consulted merchants and they assured him that a boy or a girl before twelve years old is simply no saleable commodity.

Host 1

And even when they do hit twelve years old, if you try to sell them on the exchange, they will only yield about three pounds, or maybe three pounds and a half a crown at absolute maximum.

Host 2

Which mathematically doesn't even cover the overhead.

Host 1

So it's a terrible ROI.

Host 2

Exactly. It's a bad return on investment. It cannot turn to account, either to the parents or to the kingdom.

Host 1

So if you are reading this in 1729, what does this all mean? The projector has built a perfectly logical airtight case.

Host 2

He really has.

Host 1

He has shown you the misery, he has shown you the math, he has proven that the current system is operating a massive loss. He has completely numbed you with dry utilitarian language.

Host 2

If we connect this to the psychology of the reader, the mechanism Swift is using is brilliant. By the time you read through all these deductions, subtracting 30,000 here, 50,000 there, talking about the yield price on the exchange, your guard is completely down.

Host 1

You're just bored.

Host 2

Right. You are reading a boring economic treatise. You are ready for a boring economic solution. The spreadsheet has lulled you to sleep.

Host 1

And that is when he springs the trap. He says, I shall now therefore humbly propose my own thoughts, which I hope will not be liable to the least objection.

Host 2

The pitch drop.

Host 1

We've done the math. We have 120,000 useless children. The stage is set for the projector's fair, cheap, and easy method to solve the crisis. And how does he frame the introduction of this idea? He doesn't take credit for it himself. Oh, he doesn't. He relies on foreign authority.

Host 2

Yes. He says, I've been assured by a very knowing American of my acquaintance in London.

Host 1

I want to stop there because that detail is so specific.

Host 2

It is.

Host 1

Why an American? Why not a French acquaintance or a German acquaintance? What is the mechanism behind using an American as his expert?

Host 2

It's all about colonial anthropology and eighteenth century prejudice. To an English or Irish reader in 1729, an American acquaintance would have immediately evoked the new world.

Host 1

Oh.

Host 2

It was the place they associated with the untamed wilderness, indigenous tribes, and what they considered savagery.

Host 1

So it's coded language.

Host 2

Exactly. By citing an American, Swift is subtly signaling to the reader that what is about to follow is something entirely outside the bounds of civilized European norms. It's a calculated mechanism to introduce barbarism under the guise of worldly expertise.

Host 1

And here is the reveal. I will just read it because there's no way to soften it.

Host 2

Go ahead.

Host 1

The projector solution, courtesy of this American acquaintance, is that a young, healthy child, well nursed, is at a year old, quote, a most delicious, nourishing and wholesome food, whether stewed, roasted, baked, or boiled. And I make no doubt that it will equally serve in a fricacy or a rag. Unquote.

Host 2

There it is. The pivot to cannibalism.

Host 1

This is exactly what I meant by the tech bro analogy earlier. Imagine a modern TED talk. You have a guy in a crisp button-down shirt with a headset mic pacing the stage. The screen behind him shows standard Silicon Valley disruption metrics. He's talking about synergizing excess demographic vectors and optimizing biological yield.

Host 2

The audience is just nodding along.

Host 1

Yeah, exactly. And then he clicks his little remote to the next slide, and it's just a picture of a baby in a roasting pan.

Host 2

Wow.

Host 1

And he doesn't change his tone of voice. He just keeps talking about fricacies and ragoosts, as if he's pitching a new app for food delivery. The spreadsheet is God, and the spreadsheet says eat the babies.

Host 2

That is the exact tonal dissonance Swift is aiming for. The horror isn't just the cannibalism, it's the mundane culinary logistics that immediately follow it.

Host 1

Yeah.

Host 2

The projector doesn't treat this as a shocking moral taboo. He treats it as a supply chain management issue.

Host 1

Let's look at that supply chain because the math comes right back in. Out of the a hundred and twenty thousand children, he says we need to reserve 20,000 for breed. We need to keep the population going so we don't run out of inventory. Right. And he specifies the ratio. Only one fourth part of those 20,000 should be males.

Host 2

And his justification for this ratio is incredibly degrading. He says this ratio of one male to four females is more than we allow to sheep, black cattle, or swine.

Host 1

Again, the complete reduction of humanity to livestock.

Host 2

Yep. He even notes that because these children are seldom, the fruits of marriage, which he casually mentions is a circumstance not much regarded by our savages. One male will be perfectly sufficient to serve four females.

Host 1

Our savages. He is talking about the poor Irish citizens completely dehumanizing them. Exactly. So we save 20,000 for breeding. That leaves a clean hundred thousand remaining infants. And these, at a year old, are to be offered in sale to the persons of quality and fortune through the kingdom.

Host 2

He even offers quality control advice. He advises the mothers to let the babies suck plentifully in the last month so as to render them plump and fat for a good table.

Host 1

It's revolting, but he just keeps going into the weight metrics.

Host 2

He loves the metric.

Host 1

He reckons upon a medium that a child just born will weigh twelve pounds, and in a solar year, if tolerably nursed, it increases to twenty-eight pounds.

Host 2

He's pricing it by the pound.

Host 1

Yes. And then he does the portion control. He calculates that one child will make two dishes at an entertainment for friends. If the family dines alone, the four or hind quarter will make a reasonable dish.

Host 2

He even suggests that if you season it with a little pepper or salt, it will be very good boiled on the fourth day, especially in winter.

Host 1

Wow.

Host 2

It's the language of a frugal housewife managing Sunday's roast leftovers. Right. The juxtaposition of domestic thriftiness with infant cannibalism is what makes the satire so blistering. You are forced to hold two completely incompatible ideas in your head at the same time. Wholesome domestic economy and utter barbarism.

Host 1

And right in the middle of all these culinary tips, Swift drops what I think is the most biting, incredible line in the entire text.

Host 2

Well, I know the one.

Host 1

It is the ultimate dig at the ruling class, and it really exposes the core of what he's writing about. The projector grants that this new food will be somewhat dearer, meaning expensive, and therefore it is very proper for landlords, who, as they have already devoured most of the parents, seem to have the best title to the children.

Host 2

Yeah, that's the knockout punch.

Host 1

It really is.

Host 2

If we connect this to the broader historical picture, that one sentence reveals the entire underlying purpose of the essay. Swift is addressing the absentee English landlords and the wealthy Anglo Irish elite. Right. He is saying, look, you have already consumed these people economically, you have taxed them into starvation, you have extracted every ounce of wealth from their land, their crops, their cattle, you have metaphorically eaten them alive.

Host 1

So why not just drop the pretense and literally eat their children?

Host 2

Exactly.

Host 1

You have the best title to them anyway. It's such a sharp blade. Yeah. It's basically a massive indictment of predatory capitalism long before that term even existed.

Host 2

It's incredibly modern in that sense.

Host 1

And after slipping that knife in, the projector immediately goes right back to the economics of the trade.

Host 2

Well, he has to maintain the persona. He has to prove the profitability of the scheme to his investor.

Host 1

Right. So he breaks down the margins. He calculated earlier that nursing a beggar's child costs about two shillings a year, rags included. Now he believes no gentleman would repine or complain about paying ten shillings for the carcass of a good fat child.

Host 2

Which leaves a very healthy profit margin.

Host 1

Exactly. The mother deducts her two shillings of overhead, and she has eight shillings of neat profit. Plus, without the baby to feed, she is immediately fit for work until she produces another child.

Host 2

It's a win-win in the projector's eyes.

Host 1

Totally. The squire gets excellent nutritive meat, grows popular among his tenants for his refined taste, and the mother gets capital.

Host 2

But the projector isn't done optimizing. A true entrepreneur always looks for secondary revenue streams.

Host 1

Oh no.

Host 2

For those who are more thrifty, he offers a way to utilize the byproducts.

Host 1

Yes, the flaying of the carcass. He suggests that the skin of the child artificially dressed will make admirable gloves for ladies and summer boots for fine gentlemen.

Host 2

And he even proposes the urban infrastructure to support this new industry.

Host 1

Of course he does.

Host 2

He suggests appointing shambles, which were slaughterhouses in the most convenient parts of the city of Dublin. He assures the reader that butchers will not be wanting. Though, in a truly gruesome refinement, he recommends buying the children alive and dressing them hot from the knife as we do roasting pigs.

Host 1

It is just layer upon layer of macabre detail. But to make this absolutely unhinged narrator seem somehow reasonable, Swift uses a brilliant rhetorical trick.

Host 2

Right.

Host 1

He has the projector thoughtfully consider and then reject alternative ideas for being quote unquote too extreme.

Host 2

It's a classic negotiation tactic. You present an anchor point that is so outrageously extreme that it makes your actual extreme proposal seem perfectly moderate by comparison.

Host 1

So a very worthy person, a true lover of his country, offers a refinement upon the projector scheme. This friend notices that the gentlemen of the kingdom have recently destroyed their deer populations.

Host 2

Right.

Host 1

They hunted them to near extinction. They are out of venison. So this patriot suggests that the want of venison might be well supplied by the bodies of young lads and maidens, specifically those between the ages of twelve and fourteen.

Host 2

Since they are already starving for want of work and service, they could be disposed of by their parents or nearest relations. It's the teenage venison plan.

Host 1

The teenage venison plan. And honestly, as an analogy, this perfectly captures how the wealthy deplete resources. They ate all the deer, so now they just move one step down the food chain to the poor teenagers.

Host 2

Yeah, pretty much.

Host 1

But the projector, in all his infinite wisdom and rationality, says, No, no, with due deference to my excellent friend, I cannot be altogether in his sentiments. And he breaks down the rational objections to eating teenagers.

Host 2

And notice the grounds on which he objects. It's never about morality, it's always about quality and economics. First, he consults his American acquaintance again.

Host 1

The meat expert.

Host 2

Right. And the American assures him from frequent experience that the flesh of teenage males is generally tough and lean, like that of her schoolboys, because of their continual exercise.

Host 1

So they're just too chewy.

Host 2

Basically.

Host 1

Okay, but what about the teenage females? They aren't as tough.

Host 2

The projector argues that it would be a loss to the public because those twelve to fourteen year old girls are about to become breeders themselves. Right. You don't eat the factory that produces your commodity.

Host 1

But then he adds a third objection, which is just the absolute pinnacle of hypocrisy.

Host 2

Oh, this part is amazing.

Host 1

He says, Besides, it is not improbable that some scrupulous people might unjustly censure such a practice as a little bordering upon cruelty.

Host 2

Which is astounding.

Host 1

It really is. Let me make sure I have this right. He says cruelty has always been within the strongest objection against any project.

Host 2

Right.

Host 1

The narrator bristles at the cruelty of eating a 14-year-old while he is currently actively advocating for the mass slaughter of a hundred thousand one-year-old infants. How does that logic even hold up?

Host 2

Well, it doesn't hold up morally, but it perfectly highlights the profound cognitive dissonance of the bureaucratic mind.

Host 1

Yeah.

Host 2

He can justify the industrial slaughter of infants because the math works out perfectly. They have negative economic value and they yield a good meat ratio. They are a pure commodity. Right. But the teenager who can walk and talk crosses some arbitrary line of sentimentality for him. It's a brilliant mockery of how societies decide which atrocities are acceptable business practices and which are cruel.

Host 1

And to try and justify his friend's venison idea to show that his friend wasn't totally crazy, the projector brings up this bizarre historical anecdote. He says his friend got the idea from the famous Salmanazor, a native of the island of Formosa, which is modern day Taiwan.

Host 2

This is a fascinating historical Easter egg that Swift included, and it goes right back to that idea of false authority.

Host 1

Okay, tell me more about this guy.

Host 2

George Solmanazar was a real person in early 18th century London, but he was a complete fraud. He was actually a blonde haired, blue eyed Frenchman who somehow managed to convince British high society that he was a native of Formosa.

Host 1

Wait, a blonde Frenchman convinced everyone he was from Taiwan. How?

Host 2

He preyed on their ignorance and their hunger for exoticism. He invented an entirely fake language, a fake alphabet, and wrote a completely fabricated best selling book about Formosan culture. That's wild. And in that book, he included wild tales of cannibalism and human sacrifice, because he knew that's what the European elite wanted to read about savages.

Host 1

That context makes this reference even better. Yeah. So the projector is literally citing a known proven fraud as his authoritative source for why eating teenagers might be a good idea. He says Salmanazor told his friend that in Formosa, when a young person is put to death, the executioner sells the carcass to persons of quality as a prime dainty. He specifically mentions a plump 15-year-old girl who was crucified for trying to poison the emperor, and her body was sold in joints, from the gibbet to the prime minister, and great mandarins for 400 crowns.

Host 2

Swift is using this to show how the text relies on false authority and exoticism to justify barbarism at home.

Host 1

Just completely manufactured facts.

Host 2

Exactly. It's saying, look, these sophisticated foreign courts are doing it. We read about it in a book. Why shouldn't we apply it to our own economy?

Host 1

And the projector even quips that if the same use were made of several plump young girls in Dublin who spend all their time racking up debt on foreign fineries, the kingdom wouldn't be the worse for it.

Host 2

He just can't help himself.

Host 1

It's relentless. But you know, reading this, I kept wondering if the babies are food and the teenagers are tough venison, what about everyone else? What about the sick, the maimed, the elderly?

Host 2

Right.

Host 1

What is the projector's grand scheme for the vast number of poor people who are aged or diseased? Surely he has a spreadsheet cell for them to ease the nation of that encumbrance.

Host 2

The text dismissal of the elderly is perhaps one of its most chilling moments, precisely because it requires no action at all. It requires no innovation.

Host 1

Wait, what does he say?

Host 2

The projector says he is not in the least pain upon that matter. Why? Because it is very well known that they are every day dying and rotting by cold and famine and filth and vermin as fast as can be reasonably expected.

Host 1

As fast as can be reasonably expected. That is so dark. The problem is solving itself through sheer calculated neglect.

Host 2

Exactly. The system is already doing the work of killing them, so the projector doesn't need to intervene. Then he says the young laborers are in just as hopeful a condition. They can't get work, they pine away from malnutrition, and if they do get hired for common labor, they don't have the strength to perform it. Thus, the country and themselves are happily delivered from the evils to come.

Host 1

It's so grim.

Host 2

Yeah.

Host 1

Having cleared the board of all these alternative plans and encumbrances, the projector finally gets down to brass tacks.

Host 2

Yes.

Host 1

He organizes his argument into six distinct, highly logical selling points. The six advantages of the scheme.

Host 2

This is where Swift really dissects the societal rot of his time. Each of these six advantages is a Trojan horse. On the surface, there are selling points for cannibalism. Inside, they are scathing indictments of 18th century society.

Host 1

Let's go through them. Because each one is a mini masterpiece of critique. Advantage number one. It will greatly lessen the number of papists or Catholics. Right. The text notes that infant flesh will be plentiful in March and a little before and after. Why? Because a grave French physician told them that fish is a prolific diet, meaning it makes people fertile. So there are more children born in Roman Catholic countries about nine months after Lent.

Host 2

Which means a year after Lent, the markets will be glutted.

Host 1

Yep. The projector calculates the number of Popish infants is at least three to one in the kingdom. So eating them lessens the papist population, who he describes as our most dangerous enemies who stay home on purpose to deliver the kingdom to the pretender.

Host 2

Again, staying completely impartial to the actual religious conflict. What we are seeing here is Swift highlighting the intense demographic paranoia of the Protestant ruling class. By listing genocide via digestion as an economic perk, he is mocking the idea that wiping out a religious demographic is a valid polite state goal.

Host 1

Precisely. It exposes the quiet bigotry behind economic policy. Now, advantage number two focuses on macroeconomics. The poorer tenants will finally have something valuable of their own, which by law may be made liable to a distress and help to pay their landlord's rent.

Host 2

Because, as he notes, their corn and cattle are already seized, and money is a thing unknown.

Host 1

The landlords have taken literally everything else, so giving them the babies to sell means the landlords finally get their rent money. It's that landlord dig from earlier codified into state policy. The landlords want their pound of flesh, literally.

Host 2

Advantage number three is the nationalist economic argument.

Host 1

Okay, what's that one?

Host 2

The nation's stock will be increased by 50,000 pounds per annum, plus the profit of a new dish introduced to the tables of all gentlemen of fortune who have any refinement in taste.

Host 1

And the money circulates internally. The goods are entirely of their own growth and manufacture. It's a closed loop economic boom, no import tariffs.

Host 2

Which leads to advantage number four relief for the breeders.

Host 1

Right.

Host 2

The constant breeders, besides gaming their eight shillings profit per child, will be rid of the charge of maintaining them after the first year. They are freed from the financial burden of parenthood.

Host 1

Advantage number five is all about tavern culture and the hospitality industry.

Host 2

Yes, the foodies.

Host 1

This new food will bring great custom to taverns. The vendors will procure the best recipes for dressing it to perfection. Their houses will be frequented by all the fine gentlemen who justly value themselves upon their knowledge in good eating.

Host 2

He is skewering the wealthy elite here. The foodie culture of the 18th century. He notes that a skillful cook who knows how to oblige his guests will contrive to make it as expensive as they please.

Host 1

So it's a status symbol.

Host 2

It's all about conspicuous consumption. The wealthy will eat the poor just to prove they have the refined palate and the wealth to afford it. It's the ultimate flex for them.

Host 1

But it's the sixth advantage that I really want to linger on. Because this one genuinely blew my mind. Advantage number six. It will induce marriage and maternal care and create domestic harmony.

Host 2

This is a wild one. Walk us through the mechanics of his logic here. How does cannibalis equal domestic harmony?

Host 1

Okay. The projector says that right now, out of sheer desperation, mothers abandon or murder their babies. But if the babies are suddenly worth 10 shillings, it will increase the care and tenderness of mothers towards their children.

Host 2

Because they're an asset now.

Host 1

Right. They will be sure of a settlement for life for the poor babes. We would see an honest emulation among married women to see who could bring the fattest child to the market.

Host 2

The commodification creates care.

Host 1

Exactly. But here is the darkest part. He says men would become as fond of their wives during the time of their pregnancy as they are now with their mares in foal, their cows and casts, or their sows when they are ready to ferrow. Wow. And they would no longer offer to beat or kick them. Which he notes in parentheses is too frequent a practice for fear of a miscarriage.

Host 2

So, what does this actually tell us about the world Swift was living in?

Host 1

It tells us that Swift is exposing a horrific reality of 18th century domestic life. He is claiming, and the satire only works if it's based on a recognizable truth, that men of this era literally treated their livestock better than their own pregnant wives.

Host 2

That is just deeply disturbing.

Host 1

A farmer wouldn't kick a pregnant cow because he might lose the calf, which has monetary value on the market, but he would beat his wife because the human baby had no value. Swift is saying if we put a price tag on the baby, maybe men will stop committing domestic violence. It is such a devastating, incredibly dark societal critique.

Host 2

It is the ultimate reduction of human relationships to market forces. Love, care, safety, they only exist if there is a profit motive.

Host 1

Exactly.

Host 2

And he casually lists a few other minor advantages, like exporting barreled beef because they are eating babies instead, or making better bacon because they won't eat as many pigs, since a fat yearling child roosted whole is far superior for a Lord Mayor's feast.

Host 1

But he skips over those to be brief. And having laid out this airtight, mathematically sound, entirely monstrous argument, we finally arrive at the core of the essay.

Host 2

Yes.

Host 1

This is the moment where the mask slips. This is Swift's actual manifesto.

Host 2

Up until now, Swift has been entirely hidden behind the projector persona. But here he drops the mask just enough to reveal his true political and economic demands.

Host 1

And he does it brilliantly, disguises a list of things not to do.

Host 2

Right. If we connect this to the bigger picture, this is a rhetorical master stroke.

Host 1

So the projector says he can think of no one objection to his proposal except that the population of the kingdom would be lessened, which he freely admits was his principal design. He wants to calculate a remedy for Ireland and nowhere else. And then he says, therefore, let no man talk to me of other expedients.

Host 2

If we look at the rhetorical mechanics here, this is a classic device known as apophysis. It is the act of bringing up a subject by denying that it should be brought up. You mention something by explicitly stating you won't mention it.

Host 1

Like a politician saying, I won't even bring up my opponent's terrible voting record or their recent scandal.

Host 2

Exactly. You just brought it up. You planted it in the listener's head.

Host 1

Right.

Host 2

And Swift uses apophysis to fire off a frantic, incredibly dense list of actual rational, sane policies that he genuinely believes would save Ireland. But he has the projector dismiss them all as impossible utopian dreams.

Host 1

I get to read through this list, but we need to stop and actually talk about what these mean. Because this is basically the eighteenth century equivalent of an urgent political platform.

Host 2

Definitely. Let's break them down.

Host 1

He says, Let no man talk to me of these expedients first, of taxing our absentees at five shillings a pound.

Host 2

Let's unpack that. Absentees refers to the absentee English landlords. These were wealthy individuals who owned massive tracts of land in Ireland, collected exorbitant rents from the Irish tenants, but lived in London.

Host 1

So they're just siphoning money out.

Host 2

Right. They never spent that money in Ireland. It was massive capital flight. Swift is begging for a tax on them to keep some wealth in the country.

Host 1

Then he says, Let no man talk to me of using neither clothes nor household furniture, except what is of our own growth and manufacture, and utterly rejecting the materials and instruments that promote foreign luxury.

Host 2

This is a direct response to British trade restrictions. The British government had passed laws, like the Wool Act that severely restricted Ireland's ability to export its own manufactured goods.

Host 1

Which forces them to rely on British imports.

Host 2

Exacturing. Swift is proposing a domestic boycott by local, where local, build a domestic economy to break the dependence on foreign luxury goods that are draining their wealth.

Host 1

Then he moves to social reforms. Let no man talk to me of curing the expensiveness of pride, vanity, idleness, and gaming in our women, of introducing a vein of parsimony, prudence, and temperance, of learning to love our country, of quitting our animosities and factions, not acting like the Jews who are murdering one another at the very moment their city was taken.

Host 2

He's pleading for internal unity. He sees the Irish populace deeply divided by petty factions, wasting what little money they have on vanity or gambling, while the entire nation is essentially under siege by poverty and oppressive policies.

Host 1

And then the most direct please, of teaching landlords to have at least one degree of mercy towards their tenants, and lastly, of putting a spirit of honesty, industry, and skill into our shopkeepers.

Host 2

That is Swift's real voice breaking through the satire right there.

Host 1

You can hear the profound exhaustion in it.

Host 2

Absolutely. These are all the things he had been writing about, preaching about, and campaigning for over the past decade. Economic independence, fair taxation, landlord mercy, domestic unity, and all of it had been completely ignored by the ruling class.

Host 1

The projector says, therefore I repeat, let no man talk to me of these and the like expedients till he hath at least some glimpse of hope that there will ever be some hearty and sincere attempt to put them into practice.

Host 2

That is the tragedy at the center of the satire. Swift states, through the narrator, that he's been wearied out for many years with offering vain, idle, visionary thoughts, and at length utterly despairing of success.

Host 1

Wow.

Host 2

He only resorted to suggesting baby eating because all his sane actual proposals for economic and moral reform were treated as visionary nonsense by those in power.

Host 1

He essentially concludes by challenging the politicians who dislike his cannibal overture.

Host 2

Yeah, he calls them out.

Host 1

He says, If you have a better idea, first tell me how you're going to find food and raiment for a hundred thousand useless mouths. And second, go ask the parents of these starving mortals if they wouldn't have thought it a great happiness to have been sold for food at a year old.

Host 2

To avoid the misery they're in.

Host 1

Right. And thereby avoided the perpetual scene of misfortunes, landlord oppression, and starvation they have endured.

Host 2

He is risking a deeply uncomfortable question. Is my hypothetical instantaneous cannibalism really worse than the actual agonizingly slow starvation you are inflicting on them right now through your policies?

Host 1

And he ends the entire essay with the ultimate disclaimer of pure objectivity. The projector professes in the sincerity of his heart that he has no personal interest in promoting this work.

Host 2

Of course not.

Host 1

He's only doing it for the public good. He has no children by which he can propose to get a single penny. His youngest is nine years old, and his wife is past childbearing.

Host 2

He is conflict free, a completely unbiased bureaucrat to the very end, stepping back from his spreadsheet of horrors and washing his hands of it.

Host 1

It is an absolutely stunning piece of writing. Swift wanted these ideas, this anger, this desperate plea for reform, distributed to the public for the betterment of society. He wanted his pamphlet read far and wide to shock people into action.

Host 2

And that brings us to the second part of our source material.

Host 1

Yes, because earlier we talked about how the projector viewed human beings entirely as commodities, how he tried to assign a monetary value to human life. But today, you and I are accessing this 1729 text through an organization built entirely on the exact opposite premise, Project Gutenberg.

Host 2

It is the perfect philosophical counterweight to Swiss Projector.

Host 1

It really is.

Host 2

Swift wrote about the darkest commodification of humanity, and Project Gutenberg exists to decommodify human knowledge.

Host 1

Though I have to say, reading the legal licensing of Project Gutenberg immediately after reading Swift, it's a wild experience.

Host 2

Oh, the legal jargon.

Host 1

Yeah. Because on the surface, the Project Gutenberg license reads exactly like the Projector's dry numerical math.

Host 2

Yeah.

Host 1

It is filled with section one dot E.1 and paragraph one dot F.3 and percentages and limited warranties.

Host 2

It definitely carries that same bureaucratic, legalistic tone, but the underlying mechanics are what matter. Right. Pulling the key details from the source, we see that Project Gutenberg was founded by Professor Michael S. Hart. He was the originator of the concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared with anyone. For 40 years, he produced and distributed these ebooks with only a loose network of volunteer support.

Host 1

The source tells us that in 2001, the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created. It's a nonprofit 501c3 educational corporation based in New Jersey. They rely entirely on volunteers and donations from people in all walks of life. Small donations, one to five thousand dollars, to keep the lights on and maintain their tax exempt status.

Host 2

And their core goal, their mission statement, is the free distribution of electronic works that are unprotected by U.S. copyright law. They want them available in plain vanilla ASCII or other formats, readable by the widest variety of computers, including obsolete, old, middle-aged, and new computers.

Host 1

And here's where the contrast with Swift's essay is just beautiful. The projector in Swift's essay was obsessed with the 10 shilling sale price. He wanted to hoard human lives and turn them into a proprietary luxury good for the wealthy elite. He wanted to extract eight shillings profit out of a tragedy.

Host 2

Even the Gutenberg license talks about commercial terms if someone tries to sell their free books. It mandates a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits if you charge for access to a Gutenberg work without removing their trademark.

Host 1

Right. But look at the mechanism of that royalty fee. It exists solely to protect the free distribution.

Host 2

Exactly.

Host 1

The projector used math to enslave and consume. Project Gutenberg uses legalese and percentages to ensure that the intellectual legacy of humanity cannot be hoarded or commodified.

Host 2

It's a really powerful inversion of the bureaucratic text.

Host 1

They are taking works like Swift's, works that were once locked in physical books that had to be bought and sold by the wealthy, and ensuring that they remain entirely free, unrestricted, and accessible to anyone, anywhere in the United States and most parts of the world.

Host 2

It is a profound democratization of knowledge. The projector believed only the wealthy had the best title to the children of the poor. Project Gutenberg believes that every single person, even a student with an obsolete computer, has the best title to the combined knowledge and literature of human history.

Host 1

Swift would have probably loved the idea that his desperate plea for the poor is now freely distributed to the masses without any landlord or aristocrat taking a cut of the profit.

Host 2

So, as we wrap up our review of this incredible piece of literature, let's look back at the journey we've taken today.

Host 1

We started in the tragic, crowded, starving streets of 1729 Dublin. We walked through the horrifying, mathematically sound but completely unhinged proposal of industrial cannibalism.

Host 2

We unpacked the cold logic of the projector, the absurdity of the teenage venison plan, the six terrifyingly rational advantages, and ultimately found the underlying desperate plea for societal empathy hidden in Swift's discarded expedience.

Host 1

We saw how a fake tech bro from the 18th century exposed the cruelty of an entire empire.

Host 2

And finally, we looked at the modern digital librarians, the volunteers at Project Gutenberg who are fighting to preserve this text and ensure its free distribution in the modern age. It is a journey from the absolute darkest commodification of humanity to the brightest decommodification of art.

Host 1

But as we close, there's a final thought I want you to mull over. We read a modest proposal today, and we laugh at the obvious absurdity.

Host 2

Because it's so extreme.

Host 1

Right. We know it's a joke. We know we aren't gonna literally eat babies. But look around at modern corporate structures, look at algorithmic gig economies or bureaucratic policies that reduce human lives to mere data points on a spreadsheet.

Host 2

When the projectors of our era, the tech CEOs, the policy wonks, the algorithmic planners, when they present their perfectly logical, mathematically sound, fictionless solutions to poverty or labor or health care, are we sure we aren't just nodding along to a new modest proposal without even realizing it?

Host 1

That is a chilling thought to leave on. The spreadsheet might be digital now, but the mindset is exactly the same. You have to watch out for the projectors. Thank you for joining us on this deep dive into Swift's world.

Host 2

Keep questioning the math.

More Podcasts from A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift
The cold logic of eating babies
22m

Save to playlist

Manage playlists →

Share